Caught playing politics, Jose Oliva pivots on firefighter cancer bill

Caught playing politics, Jose Oliva pivots on firefighter cancer bill
  • Sumo

State Rep. Jose Oliva, the Speaker of the House holding the firefighter cancer bill back all session, reversed his earlier decision and said Tuesday that he would bring HB857 — or something very similar to it — to the floor in the near future.

The legislation, four years in the making, aims to address healthcare shortfalls for firefighters who, because they are exposed to toxic burning substances, are diagnosed with cancer at a rate 9% higher than the rest of us and die of cancer at a 14% rate higher than the rest of us.

It has 82 sponsors from both sides of the aisle, more than any other measure possibly in history, and is certain to pass.

But Oliva wouldn’t let it go to committee. He released a statement weeks ago about this being better handled at the local level and not wanting to take control away from municipalities. But there are other bills moving through the House — including a bill that allows pet stores to sell puppy mill breeds — that would take local control away from cities and towns that want to ban those sales (more on that later).

Read related: Jose Oliva holds firefighter cancer bill hostage for political payback

He not only held the cancer bill back, Oliva also refused to respond to firefighters or the relatives of sick and fallen firefighters. He did not return their calls and emails. He did not respond to hand-delivered letters.

Only after Ladra exposed that the real motive behind the hold-up of the bill was political retaliation — and published his cellphone number so he could no longer hide from people — did Oliva say he changed his mind.

See? A Coral Gables firefighter named David Perez ran for senate last year in the open seat left by Rene Garcia. Former State Rep. Manny Diaz, Jr., who is an Oliva-made yes-man, also ran for the seat. And this gave the firefighters an opportunity to endorse one of their own.

That irked Oliva and his buddy, former State Rep. Frank Artiles, a staple in the Capitol this session even though he is not allowed to lobby for another three or four days. Artiles — who had been forced to resign after he made some racist remarks in a drunken rant — even wrote a comment on a David Perez Facebook post threatening to hold up this very cancer presumption bill as political payback.

This is not “according to” Ladra or Political Cortadito, like The Miami Herald and the Tallahassee Democrat stated. Ladra posted a screen save of the comment. Everyone can see it for themselves. It is posted here again.

And only after that political vendetta was exposed in Political Cortadito did Oliva change course, announcing it in another statement Tuesday.

“The debate this year, as in past years, was never against firefighters, nor was it political. It was the legislature that supported the funding to establish the proper need to begin with. Unfortunately, the debate became about whether we support our firefighter — of course we do. And it became about whether it was political — of  course it wasn’t. Still, the environment has become too toxic to debate the true original disagreement. As such, we will move legislation forward more so as the differences are not so great as to invite the assumptions now being made.”

First off, there was never an intention to “debate the true original disagreement,” as he says. If there was, it would have gone to committee for said debate. Instead, it was shelved so nobody could discuss it. He never had any intention to debate it in Tallahassee because he said it was a local issue.

Secondly, he said he would move legislation forward, not the legislation, which means he is still holding up the House bill and plans to present something different, perhaps the Senate Bill, as he indicated to Miami Fire Chief Joseph Zahralban, who sent an email about the conversation to his ranks.

Thirdly, if “the differences are not so great as to invite the assumptions now being made,” then why hold it up in the first place.

Lastly, the word “assumptions” is wrong. It should read conclusions. Because there was absolutely no other reason to hold back legislation that has more support than it had ever gotten in four years — including two thirds of the House as co-sponsors — and that was similar to bills passed in 40-some states.

And because, true to his form, Artiles couldn’t hold his ire back and posted a comment on this very blog admitting to the political retaliation against the firefighters and their union, giving #thanksfrank — a social media hashtag used by his political action committee’s barely dressed consultants — new life.

Read related: GOP gets desperate in Hialeah senate race against David Perez

“MDFD local with union President Omar Blanco is responsible for choosing and backing Gillum for Governor, Ring for CFO, Shawn Shaw attorney general, David Perez (Senate candidate), Ascencio ( your friend which I called a one termer), and many local Democrats over Republicans,” he posted in a rant with so much bad grammar that he likely had a couple of drinks in ‘im.

“My brothers that I served with in the Marines are firefighters, I support firefighters and their families… However, elections have consequences and the MDFD fire Union needs to clean house!”

So, the holding back of the bill was the consequences of the firefighters union supporting Perez and other Democrat candidates. That’s not an assumption of political retaliation, Mr. Speaker. That’s a confession.

Still, thank you for changing your mind. It is the right thing to do and Ladra doesn’t really care how you got there.

Betcha he changes his cellphone number next.

3 Responses to "Caught playing politics, Jose Oliva pivots on firefighter cancer bill"

  1. Great work. The union moved their issue forward but make no mistake they used classic politics.

    But it’s a little schizophrenic. One week firefighters are just brave public servants doing a dangerous job nobody else wants to do at great personal expense and being bullied by those nasty politicians .
    The next they are a political powerhouse righting wrongs and standing up for a just cause. (See political Cortadito unions-flex-political-muscle-miami-dade. 8/2014)
    Can we decide which?
    This bill is a huge expense for some communities and in Miami-Dade firefighter are already some of the highest paid individuals in our community with very generous health care and work-comp benefits $150k salaries are common.
    Buy this no longer about taxes and cost effective management of a county department this is union flexing it political muscle and leveraging the grief of a very unfortunate co-worker for additional benefits they haven’t been successful negotiating on their community level

    Come to think of it isn’t that what they did with saving their fireboats when one of their own the ex-fireman/fire chief/ current mayor identified those is overpriced?

    (note the fire department: half dozen guys cruising around the Sand bar on Sunday afternoons in their $3 million boat “monitoring the situation“ isn’t really helping your argument about cost-effective life safety issues)

    • No fan, there is no doubt that unions are political. They are supposed to be political. That is what they are for. They have the right to be. Just like the rest of us. And they have the right to have no fear of retaliation for their political beliefs, like the rest of us.

      But the unions don’t get the benefit. The firefighters do. The unions fight for their members — and they were losing this one until there was public pressure.

      Furthermore, I know a lot of firefighters. I mean a lot. One of my best friends is a firefighter. None of the ones I know make that kind of dough. That’s an exception, not the rule. And usually those salaries are for administrators and those high in the ranks — not the guys that rush into the burning buildings.

      Also, the economic impact to the state and municipalities STATEWIDE is estimated at $5 million. That doesn’t seem undoable to me. Governments waste far more money on unnecessary studies. In Miami Dade, each of the commissioners has a million dollar slush fund (more on that later).

      Also, all of the firefighters I know and have talked to — every SINGLE ONE — hopes they NEVER have to use these benefits. These benefits only kick in if you are diagnosed with one of the 21 cancers and ONLY BECAUSE studies show firefighters get and die of cancer at a higher rate than the rest of us. And not all cancers are covered. If a firefighter gets pancreatic cancer, for example, it’s tough luck. This benefit only covers the 21 specific cancers that studies have shown could be job related.

      These men and women put their own lives in peril every single hour of every single day they work to save ours. This is the LEAST we can do for them.

      Love, Ladra

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.