The long fight over the operation of the Coral Gables Country Club took a Draconian turn Wednesday when police arrived to evict the company that has leased the historic public property for more than a decade — and which has been at odds with the city over the terms (read: payments) for years.
Employees and representatives of the operator, Coral Grand, had to vacate the premises, leaving all their furnishings, equipment, files and food behind, after a judge granted the city a temporary injunction appointing a receiver, or a third party to ensure the interest of the club members when there is a financial dispute. This despite the fact the lease — which was extended until the city can take over operations itself — ends on April 30 and the company has a month to move after that, according to the contract.
In fact, there are two weddings planned for this weekend, said attorney David Winker, who is representing the company and owner Nick Di Donato.
“In almost thirty years of practice, I have never seen such a blatant attempt to misuse the Court as Plaintiff’s corrupt effort to steal Defendant’s private property,” Winker writes in his motion. “American citizens do not normally have to be worried about government officials obtaining secret orders in the middle of the night to seize their private property.”
Read related: Coral Gables Country Club grab deal is dead as Rodney Barreto group backs out
Actually, it was shortly before 8 p.m. when Miami-Dade County Judge Carlos Lopez signed the ex parte order appointing attorney Joel H. Brown the receiver to “ensure that the historical country club is protected and preserved for the benefit of the city and it’s citizens.”
The seizure includes personal property and bank accounts.
“A secret order signed by a judge in the middle of the night,” Winker told Ladra after he filed an emergency motion Wednesday to dissolve the receivership. “No evidence, no hearing, just cops showing up saying you have to leave immediately and we are seizing everything.
“Is this Communist China or Cuba?
Winker hopes to overturn it on Thursday, saying that it was done without giving his client any due process.
“What has happened at the Country Club is a microcosm of the city right now — special deals for special people. And if you aren’t one of the special people, you better watch out,” said Winker, who has had other cases against the city, , most notably against the secret approval of the WaWa gas station.
Read related: Zoning code ‘mistake’ in Coral Gables could make millions for developers
Or could it be sour grapes?
The city wanted to turn over the Country Club to Rodney Barreto and his partners after they presented an unsolicited bid to take over operations. They said that the current operators had defaulted on rent (during COVID) and that they weren’t forced to renew the lease. Residents balked and more than 3,000 signed a petition urging the city to keep the current operators.
The city’s late night injunction Tuesday to appoint a receivership noted that Coral Gables Grand had formed a second company to operate the fitness center — and, possibly, syphon or hide income it would have to share with the city. It isn’t the first or only time city leaders accuse the Di Donatos, who they say won’t let the city audit the premises, of theft.
If you like what you read in Political Cortadito, please consider making a donation to help Ladra keep sniffing and digging around our local government.
“They intend to use the next 30 days (through May 30, 2022) to remove marble from columns, tear out speakers and other sound equipment, remove counters and other items deemed fixtures, and load everything up in a truck that is headed for Canada where Nick resides and runs other businesses,” the city’s motion states.
So far, however, the city has not been able to prove that the company has done anything to keep more of the profits for themselves — or steal anything that doesn’t belong to them.
Instead, according to Gables Insider, this latest move comes during an impasse in negotiations over the transfer of the very same equipment and furnishings that the city has now seized. The company reportedly did not agree with the city’s lowball appraisals and rejected the offer.
Read related: Miami-Dade judge slams Coral Gables on WaWa’s secret approval process
“What is happening is that the city is stealing the Di Donatos’ equipment because they can’t operate the club without the million dollars worth of kitchen and gym equipment,” Winker said.
“This is the story of a city crossing the line into a criminal enterprise.”
Commissioners will meet behind closed doors on Thursday in a “shade meeting” allowed under Florida’s government in the sunshine laws to discuss the case. Maybe at the same time, Winker will be in court trying to get his client back inside the country club.
Emergency Motion to dissolve Country Club of Coral Gables receivership by Political Cortadito on Scribd
Fight over Coral Gables Country Club escalates with eviction and seizure added by Ladra on
View all posts by Ladra →
[…] Read related: Fight over Coral Gables Country Club escalates with eviction and seizure […]
Feel for the two couples whose weddings are caught up in this mess. City should make them whole, maybe host it at Redfish, Riviera, Fairchild Gardens…!!
As a resident of Coral Gables and one who has enjoyed both the club gym and Liberty Cafe all I can say is. It was a place my children and there’s enjoyed going to attending the many wedding and social receptions. Now what. The Riviera Club? Ridiculous….
MORE “PAY TO PLAY ” POLITICIANS WHERE LOBBYIST RULES ?
It’s what’s called a legal tiff. If one has been a resident of Southwest Miami, from the presidency of JFK, one must expect some changes in the way business is conducted here, if only by account of the massive construction in the downtown areas.
Que dramatica! The city’s suit alleges the operators are engaging in various nefarious activities. Who knows the truth? If the operators are illegally removing city property, then the city must take all lawful action. Apparently a very reputable judge felt comfortable issuing an injunction, and that means something. The operator’s attorney’s histrionics in his motion are sideshow. Quoting Karl Marx and sharing personal opinions? Really? There is nothing less meaningful than “I’ve been an attorney for ‘X’ years, and I’ve never seen anything so egregious!”.
Unfortunately the city’s poor recent history causes some doubt over its claims. The city better be able to back up its allegations. It really does not help that the city manager verified the complaint, as he has his own issues. But the same is true with the operator, which better make sure it doesn’t let its mouthpiece get carried away.
I look forward to watching this all play out and I very much appreciate your reporting on this and other matters.
Another sad chapter in the history of this once magnificent edifice, the social centerpiece of Merrick’s old Gables. From its heydays in the 50s and 60s, the slow demise of the enterprise back in the 80s and 90s eventually reached the pitiful stage when the current operator made an offer, out of the blue, to rescue and resuscitate the property. The Biltmore team, as well, offered to step in, but the idea of one entity operation both venues was soundly rejected.
The city jumped at the opportunity for private stewardship, but local legacy civic groups were rejected unceremoniously in favor of the private enterprise profit. The club lost its soul, but the city was released from obligation.
So what is the future of this community asset? To serve its community in a proper social fashion? Return to the glamorous and vibrant days of resident participation?
In the days when the Biltmore and this County Club had the only liquor licenses in Coral Gables, the old gal was guaranteed a certain level of success by default. Now, the city has a vibrant base of full-service venues. Where does the country club fit in the modern scheme of all things Coral Gables?
The city has no record of success operating such enterprises and one can only wonder if their mission will return to a public-oriented motive that enhances quality of life for all residents. Or? Not sure what other directions make sense.
We’re in a fine mess now. Let’s hope for the best.
Perhaps a talented venue operator/manager, a real leader in the field, can be enticed to step in on the city’s payroll and make something of it. Leaving it to city staff to manage under the direction of a busy city manager, at the whims of the commission, sounds risky and unlikely to enhance any of their reputations or make their constituents happy.
Rodney Barreto and his cronies are just criminals. Look how they got Coral Gables officials to break the law on their behalf.